AMS Go
Organisation

Fines for occupational safety violations in Germany: what breaches can cost

From 2,500 euros for a late accident report to one million euros for a failure of supervision: which fines German occupational safety law provides for, when a breach becomes a criminal offence, who is personally liable and how to avoid fines.

Last updated on 10 min readAMS Go editorial team

Key points at a glance

  • Breaches of fine-bearing duties under occupational safety ordinances such as the Workplaces Ordinance (ArbStättV), the Industrial Safety Ordinance (BetrSichV) or the Ordinance on Occupational Medical Care (ArbMedVV) cost up to 5,000 euros; disregarding an enforceable order of the labour inspectorate costs up to 30,000 euros (Section 25 ArbSchG).
  • Breaches of the Hazardous Substances Ordinance are more expensive (up to 50,000 euros via Section 26 of the Chemicals Act, ChemG), as are breaches involving installations subject to monitoring (up to 100,000 euros via Section 32 ÜAnlG); accident prevention regulations carry up to 10,000 euros, a missed accident report up to 2,500 euros (Section 209 SGB VII).
  • The amounts are maximums: for negligence the maximum is halved, and the authority sets the fine according to the significance of the offence, the degree of blame and the financial circumstances (Section 17 of the Administrative Offences Act, OWiG).
  • Fines do not only hit the company: managing directors, plant managers and persons appointed in writing can be fined personally (Section 9 OWiG), and a failure of supervision costs up to one million euros (Section 130 OWiG).
  • Intentional endangerment, persistent repetition or an accident causing injury can lead to criminal liability; in cases of gross negligence, the statutory accident insurance can also seek recourse (Section 110 SGB VII).

Fines at a glance: what the law provides

There is no single offence called “occupational safety violation”. Which fine applies is set out in the relevant provision: the occupational safety ordinances list their administrative offences (Ordnungswidrigkeiten) themselves and refer to a statute for the amount – usually Section 25 of the Occupational Safety and Health Act (ArbSchG), for hazardous substances the Chemicals Act, and for installations subject to monitoring the Act on Installations Subject to Monitoring (ÜAnlG). The table shows the most important maximum amounts.

  • Duty under an occupational safety ordinance breached, e.g. risk assessment not documented, work equipment not inspected, employees not instructed, mandatory occupational medical care not arranged, escape routes not kept clear

    ProvisionSection 25 (1) no. 1, (2) ArbSchG in conjunction with Section 9 ArbStättV, Section 22 (1) BetrSichV, Section 10 ArbMedVV, Section 16 LärmVibrationsArbSchV, Section 20 BioStoffV

    Fine up to5,000 euros

  • Employer or responsible person does not comply with an enforceable order of the labour inspectorate

    ProvisionSection 25 (1) no. 2 (a), (2) ArbSchG

    Fine up to30,000 euros

  • Employees do not comply with an enforceable order addressed to them

    ProvisionSection 25 (1) no. 2 (b), (2) ArbSchG

    Fine up to5,000 euros

  • Hazardous substances: e.g. risk assessment not documented, no hazardous substances register, no operating instructions, no safety instruction

    ProvisionSection 22 (1) GefStoffV, Section 26 (1) no. 8 (b), (3) ChemG

    Fine up to50,000 euros

  • Installations subject to monitoring: e.g. inspection not ensured, no emergency plan for lifts

    ProvisionSection 22 (2) BetrSichV, Section 32 (1) no. 14 (a), (2) ÜAnlG

    Fine up to100,000 euros

  • Accident prevention regulation with a reference to the fine provision breached, order of the accident insurance inspector disregarded, safety representatives not appointed

    ProvisionSection 209 (1) nos. 1 to 3a, (3) SGB VII

    Fine up to10,000 euros

  • Occupational accident not reported, reported incorrectly or late

    ProvisionSection 209 (1) no. 9, (3) in conjunction with Section 193 SGB VII

    Fine up to2,500 euros

  • Employees not informed of the competent accident insurance institution

    ProvisionSection 209 (1) no. 4, (3) in conjunction with Section 138 SGB VII

    Fine up to2,500 euros

  • Maximum working hours, rest breaks, rest periods or Sunday rest not observed, working time beyond eight hours per working day not recorded

    ProvisionSection 22 (1) nos. 1 to 7, 9, 10, (2) Working Hours Act (ArbZG)

    Fine up to30,000 euros

  • Working Hours Act not posted or made available

    ProvisionSection 22 (1) no. 8, (2) ArbZG

    Fine up to5,000 euros

  • Maternity protection: woman employed despite an employment ban, not released from work or assigned an impermissible activity

    ProvisionSection 32 (1) nos. 1 to 5, 8, 16, 17, (2) Maternity Protection Act (MuSchG)

    Fine up to30,000 euros

  • Maternity protection: risks not assessed, protective measures not defined, supervisory authority not notified

    ProvisionSection 32 (1) nos. 6, 7, 9 to 15, (2) MuSchG

    Fine up to5,000 euros

  • Protection of young workers: e.g. working hours exceeded, hazardous work, employment without a medical certificate

    ProvisionSection 58 (1), (4) Young Persons Protection of Employment Act (JArbSchG)

    Fine up to30,000 euros

  • Protection of young workers: e.g. young people not instructed about hazards, postings or register missing

    ProvisionSection 59 (1), (3) JArbSchG

    Fine up to5,000 euros

  • Enforceable order under the Occupational Safety Act disregarded, for example on appointing a company doctor or safety specialist

    ProvisionSection 20 (1) no. 1, (2) ASiG in conjunction with Section 12 ASiG

    Fine up to25,000 euros

  • Owner fails to take the necessary supervisory measures, and a breach occurs in the company

    ProvisionSection 130 OWiG

    Fine up to1 million euros if the breach is a criminal offence; otherwise the maximum fine for that breach

  • Fine against the company if a person in a management position commits a criminal or administrative offence

    ProvisionSection 30 OWiG

    Fine up to10 million euros (intentional criminal offence), 5 million euros (negligent criminal offence), otherwise the maximum for the administrative offence

How high a fine actually turns out

The amounts in the table are upper limits, not standard rates. How high a fine is in an individual case is governed by the Administrative Offences Act:

  • Negligence halves the maximum: if the fine provision does not distinguish between intent and negligence, negligent conduct can be fined at most half the maximum – under Section 25 ArbSchG, up to 2,500 or 15,000 euros (Section 17 (2) OWiG).
  • Assessment: the basis is the significance of the offence and the blame attaching to the person concerned; financial circumstances can also be taken into account (Section 17 (3) OWiG).
  • Economic benefit: the fine should exceed the benefit gained from the breach, such as saved inspection costs. If the maximum is not sufficient for this, it may be exceeded (Section 17 (4) OWiG).
  • Several breaches: a separate fine is set for each administrative offence (Section 20 OWiG) – so several deficiencies can add up.
  • Limitation period: depending on the maximum fine, prosecution becomes time-barred after six months to three years, after three years for maximum amounts above 15,000 euros (Section 31 (2) OWiG).

When a breach becomes a criminal offence

Most occupational safety breaches are administrative offences. They become criminal when someone intentionally endangers life or health, persistently disregards orders, or a person is injured or killed in an accident:

  • Enforceable order persistently disregarded, or life or health of employees endangered by an intentional breach of an ordinance

    ProvisionSection 26 ArbSchG, e.g. in conjunction with Section 9 (2) ArbStättV, Section 23 (1) BetrSichV, Section 10 (2) ArbMedVV

    PenaltyImprisonment of up to one year or a fine

  • Life or health of another person endangered by a breach of the Hazardous Substances Ordinance

    ProvisionSection 22 (2) GefStoffV, Section 27 (2) and (4) ChemG

    PenaltyImprisonment of up to five years (intentional) or up to two years (negligent), or a fine

  • Working time breach committed intentionally and endangering health, or persistently repeated

    ProvisionSection 23 ArbZG

    PenaltyImprisonment of up to one year or a fine; up to six months where the danger was caused negligently

  • Intentional breach of an employment ban endangering the health of the woman or her child

    ProvisionSection 33 MuSchG

    PenaltyImprisonment of up to one year or a fine

  • Intentional breach endangering children or young people, or persistent repetition

    ProvisionSection 58 (5) and (6) JArbSchG

    PenaltyImprisonment of up to one year or a fine; up to six months where the danger was caused negligently

  • Negligent bodily harm

    ProvisionSection 229 German Criminal Code (StGB)

    PenaltyImprisonment of up to three years or a fine

  • Negligent homicide

    ProvisionSection 222 StGB

    PenaltyImprisonment of up to five years or a fine

If an act is both a criminal and an administrative offence, only criminal law applies; an administrative fine only comes back into play if no criminal penalty is imposed (Section 21 OWiG). An omission can also be punishable if someone is legally responsible for preventing the harm (Section 13 StGB). Whether and who is criminally responsible is decided by the public prosecutor and the court in each individual case.

Action plan in AMS GoRecord deficiencies from inspections, deficiency letters and orders as measures with a responsible person and deadline, get automatic reminders and document completion with a photo or inspection record – so no deadline set by the inspectors is missed.

Fine, criminal penalty, recourse: three different consequences

Fines, criminal penalties and recourse are often lumped together. But they have different requirements, are imposed by different bodies and can occur side by side:

  • Administrative fine

    Who decidesLabour inspectorate of the federal state; for accident prevention regulations, the accident insurance institution

    RequirementAdministrative offence, intent or negligence – no accident required

    Legal basisSection 25 ArbSchG, Sections 209, 210 SGB VII, OWiG

  • Criminal penalty

    Who decidesPublic prosecutor and criminal court

    RequirementCriminal offence committed, e.g. intentional endangerment or negligent bodily harm

    Legal basisSection 26 ArbSchG, Sections 222, 229 StGB

  • Recourse

    Who decidesBerufsgenossenschaft or Unfallkasse (statutory accident insurance), possibly other social insurance institutions

    RequirementOccupational accident caused intentionally or through gross negligence

    Legal basisSections 110, 111 SGB VII

Recourse can be more expensive than any fine: the accident insurance can reclaim its expenses up to the amount of the civil-law damages claim, and instead of a pension it can claim its capital value (Section 110 (1) SGB VII). If managing directors or other authorised representatives caused the accident in this way, the company is also liable (Section 111 SGB VII). The institutions can waive the claim in whole or in part at their reasonable discretion (Section 110 (2) SGB VII).

Who is liable: company, managing directors, supervisors

Many fine provisions are addressed to “the employer”. That does not mean only the company can be held to account. Alongside the employer, the legal representatives, persons with management tasks and persons appointed in writing are responsible within the scope of their tasks and powers (Section 13 (1) ArbSchG).

  • Managing directors and executive board: fine and criminal provisions linked to the employer also apply to the authorised bodies and partners (Section 9 (1) OWiG, Section 14 (1) StGB).
  • Plant and department managers: anyone appointed to manage all or part of the business can also be held personally liable (Section 9 (2) no. 1 OWiG, Section 14 (2) no. 1 StGB).
  • Persons appointed in writing: anyone expressly appointed to perform employer duties on their own responsibility is personally liable for them (Section 13 (2) ArbSchG, Section 9 (2) no. 2 OWiG). This also applies if the appointment is invalid (Section 9 (3) OWiG).
  • Owner and management in case of inadequate supervision: the necessary supervisory measures include appointing, carefully selecting and monitoring supervisors (Section 130 (1) OWiG).
  • The company itself: if a person in a management position commits a criminal or administrative offence, a fine can also be imposed on the company (Section 30 OWiG).

How the authorities proceed

Whether the authority prosecutes a breach is at its dutiful discretion (Section 47 OWiG). Often the first step is not a fine but a request to remedy deficiencies. A typical sequence:

  1. 1

    Inspection and findings

    The inspectors – labour inspectorate or accident insurance inspector – identify deficiencies during an inspection or after an accident.

  2. 2

    Deficiency letter

    The deficiencies are communicated in writing, at the trade supervisory office often called a “Revisionsschreiben” – with a date by which you should report that they have been remedied.

  3. 3

    Order

    If deficiencies are not remedied or the danger is considerable, the authority issues a binding order specifying which measures must be taken by when; in case of imminent danger, with immediate effect (Section 22 (3) ArbSchG, Section 19 (1) SGB VII). If it is not complied with, the authority can prohibit the work or work equipment concerned.

  4. 4

    Fine proceedings

    Before a notice of fine is issued, you are given the opportunity to comment (Section 55 OWiG). You can lodge an objection to the notice within two weeks of service (Section 67 OWiG).

  5. 5

    Criminal proceedings

    In cases of persistent repetition, intentional endangerment or an accident causing injury or death, the public prosecutor becomes involved.

Checklist: how to avoid fines

  • Risk assessment carried out for all activities, documented and updated after changes – including hazardous substances, noise, maternity protection and psychological stress
  • Hazardous substances register and operating instructions complete and up to date
  • Safety instruction given before work starts and regularly thereafter, with records
  • Inspection intervals for work equipment and installations subject to monitoring tracked, inspections documented
  • Mandatory and offered occupational medical care arranged, medical care register kept
  • Sufficient first aiders trained, first aid material available, PPE provided
  • Safety specialist and company doctor appointed, safety representatives appointed where required
  • Working hours recorded, maximum working hours and rest periods observed, postings in place
  • Occupational accidents with more than three days of incapacity reported within three days
  • Transfers of duties in writing, with area and powers, and checked on a sample basis
  • Findings from deficiency letters and orders dealt with on time and documented

Frequently asked questions

How high is the fine for a missing risk assessment?

That depends on which provision has been breached. The basic duty under Sections 5 and 6 ArbSchG does not itself carry a fine, but the duties under the ordinances do: under ArbStättV, BetrSichV, LärmVibrationsArbSchV or BioStoffV, up to 5,000 euros (Section 25 ArbSchG); under the Hazardous Substances Ordinance, up to 50,000 euros (Section 26 ChemG); under the Maternity Protection Act, up to 5,000 euros (Section 32 MuSchG). If you ignore an enforceable order of the authority, up to 30,000 euros.

Can a managing director be fined personally?

Yes. Fine provisions addressed to the employer also apply to the authorised bodies, i.e. the managing directors (Section 9 (1) OWiG). If they failed to provide the necessary supervision, this can be a separate administrative offence under Section 130 OWiG. In addition, a fine can be imposed on the company under Section 30 OWiG.

Is there a catalogue of fines for occupational safety?

There is no nationwide ordinance with a catalogue of fines as there is for road traffic. The statutes only set maximum amounts; the federal states follow internal guidelines. In each case, the authority sets the fine according to the significance of the breach, the degree of blame and financial circumstances; for negligence, only half the maximum applies (Section 17 OWiG).

Does every breach of an accident prevention regulation carry a fine?

No, only if the accident prevention regulation refers to Section 209 SGB VII for that offence. DGUV Regulation 1 does so in Section 32, for example for alarm facilities to call for help (Section 25 (1)), the number of first aiders (Section 26) and the use of personal protective equipment (Section 30). Fines of up to 10,000 euros are then possible, imposed by the accident insurance institution (Sections 209, 210 SGB VII).

When does an occupational safety breach become a criminal offence?

When someone persistently disregards an enforceable order or endangers the life or health of employees through an intentional breach (Section 26 ArbSchG) – the penalty is imprisonment of up to one year or a fine. For hazardous substances, the penalty range extends to five years (Section 27 ChemG). If an accident occurs, negligent bodily harm (Section 229 StGB) or negligent homicide (Section 222 StGB) may apply.

This guide gives a general overview of German occupational safety law and does not replace legal advice. The regulations in force and the rules of the statutory accident insurance institutions are authoritative.

Organise occupational safety digitally

With the occupational safety software AMS Go you handle risk assessments, safety instructions, inspections and more in one system – mobile and with AI support.

Newsletter

Occupational safety, straight to your inbox

New templates, guides and changes to regulations – free from AMS Go. The newsletter is in German. You can unsubscribe at any time via the link in every email.

Privacy information

Contact

Get in touch

Book an appointment with us – or send us a message.

Kim Marius GräfeFrank MezlerLukas KleinBenjamin Kostrzewa

Personal and direct – with our founding team. Meet the founding team